Divorce, custody cases, property settlement, ante-nuptial agreements, post- judgment litigation and divorce mediation and arbitration are several which Jeffrey Epstein… Spouses have a preexisting agreement concerning payment and reimbursement; Payments for the mortgage or community property were intended as a gift to the other spouse; The spouse who made the community property payments continued to live in the home; or. If you and your spouse own a home you may decide that one of you will continue to live in the home while the other relocates. Nina S. Epstein is licensed to practice in New York State and Federal courts. It is probably derived from the German town of Eppstein, in Hesse; the place-name was probably derived from Gaulish apa ("water", in the sense of a river) and German -stein ("stone", in the sense of a … Thank you for the terrific work your office did with my family law matter… Your staff was brilliant and I can’t imagine where I would’ve been in this whole mess without your firm’s work and expertise.  Thanks again! No, Epstein Credits and Watts Charges are not automatic during a divorce. I cannot thank Peter and Carolyn enough for their joint effort in my matter! I am now able to move forward with my new life! Dr. Epstein is formed as BA from the University of Hartford and a law graduate with a PhD from Nova Southeastern University. If, for example, one spouse continued to live in a previously shared residence or drive a previously shared vehicle after separation, then a Watts charge may come into play. Bank records, mortgage statements, and records of payment can provide the evidence that is necessary to establish cause for an award of Epstein Credits. Jeffrey Epstein - The Family Law Specialist - Free download as Word Doc (.doc), PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Epstein Credits and Watts Charges can be complicated and it is best to contact an experienced California family law attorney if you are thinking about separating from your spouse. He kept me informed all the way through and handled a glitch at the end promptly. Even when requested, these charges and credits are discretionary and are not automatically awarded. The terms “Epstein credits,” “right to reimbursement,” and “credits” often come up during a divorce case, and refer to post-separation payments to benefit the community or other spouse. Mark is fantastic and a hands on type of lawyer who is there to help and support those in his firm when they need his help. The attorneys of Notaro Calabrese & Epstein - Divorce and Family Law Attorneys offer exceptional representation in all aspects of divorce, alimony, divorce mediation, child custody, child support, Protection from Abuse (PFA), paternity, and other domestic matters. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. We are closely monitoring the situation and have implemented the following actions: In the coming days we will continue to follow and implement any new measures as suggested by the government and health ministry of Canada. ABOUT US. Estou muito satisfeito com minha experiência com o escritório Shayne Epstein Law. If you are thinking about getting a divorce in California you may be discussing the logistics of the separation. If you and your spouse separate you exclusively pay the mortgage and/or rent for community property with separate funds, you may request to be reimbursed for your spouse’s share of that burden. This determination, however, will depend on the fair market rental value of your home and the amount paid each month toward your mortgage. You are exclusively using community property (in this case, a family home) for your own personal use and enjoyment. Community assets include real property, vehicles, furniture, and other properties of value. Have a private consultation with and retain a family law attorney to represent you and help you with such issues. If the community asset is a home, the fair market rental value would be the most accurate and appropriate figure. The Basics of Epstein Credits and Watts Charges in a Divorce. His calm personal approach was great. Family mediation is the go-to choice for couples who are looking for an amicable separation that is less costly than litigation, When administering an estate, there is the potential for uncertainties, disputes or misinterpretations from the different parties involved, Our divorce & separation services include contracts, litigation, child & spousal support, custody & access, property division, and uncontested divorce, Our family law services include contracts, litigation, child & spousal support, custody & access, property division, and uncontested divorce, The focus of collaborative family law is cooperation as opposed to confrontation, When you’re starting a business or reviewing contracts, a lawyer can help you steer clear of legal ramifications and costs, We have the experience to ensure your interests are protected, your rights defended, and your case thoroughly pursued, Purchasing or selling a home is often one of most significant financial transactions you will make in your lifetime, Epstein & Associates can help guide you through the important steps and decisions when you are preparing your will, When parties find themselves in court, Epstein & Associates can assist in settling the dispute by way of active negotiation or aggressive litigation, The relationship between Landlord and Tenant is a binding one, and thus should involve experienced, learned legal advice, Helping you navigate complex employment law issues in the Greater Toronto Area. The Basics of Epstein Credits and Watts ... - Family Law Brief Your Complete Guide to Child Support Laws In Ontario, Sussman v. Fabrega – The Importance of Both Parents Being Engaged in a Child’s Education, Rotating staff to minimize the number of people at the office at any given time, Reinforcing proper hygiene protocol with all our staff, Enforcing a 14-day self quarantine period for all staff who have decided to travel, Ensuring antibacterial stations are available, We have implemented steps to protect our staff and clients, including promoting options for telephone consultations, remote signings and video conferencing. Meet Anne. Attorney Epstein graduated from Brandeis University in 1990 with a BA in Politics. I really appreciate it. Are Epstein Credits and Watts Charges Automatic? Mark and his team helped me immensely through a very difficult time. Can You Request a Psychological Evaluation in a Child Custody Case? Anne Epstein has been practicing family law in Connecticut for more than twenty years . BRA (11) 3957-0623 USA (954) 781-1994 While spouses may be able to speak to the rental value of your home, it may be appropriate to obtain the unbiased opinion of a real estate appraiser and/or expert. The burden of proving why Epstein Credits and Watts Charges should be granted is placed on the party asking for the award. If, for example, you pay the entirety of the mortgage each month, you may request that your spouse reimburses you for 50% of that payment each month. They provided sharp, timely and empathetic counsel, for a very fair price. Kellen Melo Sem palavras. Watts charges compensate your spouse for your use of exclusive community property. We offer an affordable strategy session. A judge will consider these factors when determining if Epstein and Watts are appropriate. Epstein & Associates can help you with family law & divorce matters! It was in April 2004 he chose to join the firm as being a partner. Named after the 1985 Marriage of Watts case, a Watts charge (sometimes called a Watts credit) applies in divorce cases when one spouse uses community assets after separation. Epstein & Associates is committed to providing your matter with attention and care, which we believe, is unavailable with other lawyers in Newmarket, Richmond Hill, Mississauga and Barrie. The Epstein Law Firm New Orleans divorce lawyer and mediator practice family law, child custody, car accident litigation, personal injury law, and more. Family Law – Sometimes All in the Family . The Family Law and Mediation Offices of Lilian Epstein provide comprehensive legal services in the area of family law. Thanks again. I began practicing family law in 2014, following my own personal 2-year odyssey through the family court justice system. In 2020, I was recognized by the NC State Bar as a board-certified specialist in family law. There is no automatic right to reimbursement or credits; however, they can have a significant impact on the division of assets and obligations. Epstein Credits are generally calculated by identifying the actual amount(s) paid for the community property by the requesting spouse. Call: (504) 322-3211 Blog Find Notaro Calabrese & Epstein - Divorce and Family Law Attorneys, a Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (PA) Law Firm focused on Family Law, Wills, Mediation, etc. Located in San Jose, California, Attorney Lilian Epstein serves clients throughout Santa Clara County. I have seen many Lawyers over the past eight years, your level of professionalism is outstanding! Do not try to figure out whether Epstein Credits or Watts Charges apply to your case without proper legal advice. Watts Charges are generally calculated by determining the fair market rental value or use of a community asset. I got a fair deal and my divorce was a thing of the past.. It is obvious efficiency is one of the firm's mandates. Family Law Practice, Epstein Patierno, LLP offers clients a diversified group of experienced family law attorneys whose primary focus is the handling of complex legal issues regarding domestic relations matters involving divorce (dissolution of marriage), litigation, property, debts, maintenance and allocation of parental responsibility (child custody) issues, and many other areas of family law. At Epstein and Associates, we know that during a divorce case, one of the main concerns will be protecting your, If you’re thinking of buying a house or condo in Ontario, you’ll need a real estate lawyer to help represent, This article is a complete guide to child support laws in Ontario. Located in Vancouver, Epstein Law is an established practice that provides professional legal services in the legal areas of personal injury law, family law, estate law and business law. In addition, our Flat Fee for an uncontested divorce is: Flat Fee for an uncontested … The surname Epstein is one of the oldest Ashkenazi Jewish family names. Our principal lawyer, Mark Epstein, will give your matter the detailed attention it deserves at all times. Thank you so much for all of your help with the closing of our new home. Justin Smulison. What Does An Ontario Real Estate Lawyer Do? Epstein Credits will not be applicable if payments are made from jointly-owned or jointly-used banking accounts. COVID, Face Masks, and Parental Custody Rights, Attorneys See Divorce Rates Skyrocket in California as Consequence of COVID Lockdown. If you’re looking for a divorce lawyer, make sure to check out our guide on finding a good divorce lawyer in California. Peter handled a double real estate closing for me; he treated me with great respect. Jeffrey Epstein functions at the firm of Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader P.C. If your home is community property belonging to both you and your spouse, you may be faced with Epstein and Watts issues when you are settling your divorce. Your spouse, who is generally entitled to 50% of the value of community property, is enjoying 0% of that property’s value and use. The attorneys at Notaro Calabrese & Epstein - Divorce and Family Law Attorneys are experienced family law practitioners. Put simply: paying a Watts Charge is like paying rent. T: (303) 893-3111 @: info@epfamilylawattorneys.com F: (303) 893-0842 If you and your spouse separate and you exclusively remain in the family home after that separation, you may be asked to pay Watts Charges. Despite all the lawyer jokes out there I am actually looking forward to working with you and your staff in the future Hopefully for more positive things though; thank you again. During that process, I felt a calling to help lead others through the tunnel from which I had just emerged. I am glad I did.." A Watts charge is an obligation to the other spouse for one-half of the reasonable value for the exclusive use of a community asset after date of separation. Jeffrey joined the firm as a partner in April 2004. Contact an experienced California family law attorney to learn more. You were very quick to act on this matter, before coming to see you, I thought I would never see this Divorce happen! About Notaro Calabrese & Epstein - Divorce and Family Law Attorneys Experienced Divorce & Family Law Advocacy. Epstein & Associates is an established law firm dedicated to protecting the rights of our clients. An expert can accurately assess the value of a home and determine the fair market rent. “Knowledgeable, easily approachable, attentive and represented my interests well. It covers everything from how child support is, A recent Ontario Superior Court of Justice decision, Sussman v. Fabrega 2020 ONSC 5162, highlighted the importance of both parents, For A Free Consultation With One Of Our Lawyers, Call Today. You went over and above the call of duty and assisted me through a very difficult time in my life with compassion and understanding. Our family law firm has offices in Orange County, Los Angeles and San Diego. I felt empowered to make decisions with the information that you provided me with and now am looking forward to the next chapter in my life. Epstein Credits and Watts Charges may also be offset by one another. If, for example, you pay the entirety of your home’s mortgage payment, but also live in the home exclusively, you may not be awarded Epstein & Watts. Law Offices of Anne E. Epstein, LLC 59 Elm Street, Suite 215 New Haven, CT 06510 Telephone: (475) 234-5115 Facsimile: (475) 221-1873. email: info@anneepsteinfamilylaw.com. Philip Michael Epstein CM OOnt QC is a Canadian family law lawyer.. Epstein is the co-founder and senior partner of Epstein Cole LLP, in Toronto, Ontario.He has authored numerous publications, has acted as a policy advisor to the Canadian government on family law issues, is a regular lecturer at law schools in Toronto, and practices in mediation, arbitration, and appellate advocacy. Jeffrey Epstein functions at the firm of Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader P.C. How are Epstein Credits and Watts Charges Calculated? One Parent Moves, the Other Parent Stays, Who Pays Transportation and What Other Issues May Arise? Never did I feel there was an unnecessary upsell! The spouse that is not using the real property can make a charge against the … Our attorneys help with the following areas of family law: A spouse who is not exclusively enjoying specific community property must request Watts Charges and a spouse who is exclusively paying for community property from separate and independent funds must request Epstein Credits. It is crucial to document that payments for the subject community property are made from separate and exclusive financial accounts. As a dedicated and highly skilled family lawyer in Livingston, Robert Epstein is ready to represent your rights. Jeffrey Epstein specializes and emphasizes negotiation and trial coverage of matrimonial litigation, including divorce, custody cases, property settlement, ante-nuptial agreements, post-judgment litigation, as well as divorce mediation and arbitration. law office as being a Family Law specialist. If you are in deep sh@t.. call Larry.. At the Epstein Law Firm, we focus on your individual needs with … Call Ziegler, Resnick & Epstein today! The number of children residing in the home. Thank you so much for your assistance with my separation At a difficult time in my life it was comforting knowing that you and your firm were in my corner. law office being a Family Law specialist. Each of our attorneys was trained in Pennsylvania and provides quality, affordable, and honest legal advice to the people of Pittsburgh. Based in New Orleans, Louisiana, Jeremy Epstein practices throughout South Louisiana handling legal issues involving divorce, custody, family law, personal injury, insurance claims and other areas of legal need. I hired Larrry.. Here, we provide a brief overview of Epstein Credits and Watts Charges to help you understand your rights and obligations during a divorce. Anne Epstein attended the Benjamin Cardozo School of Law, graduating in 1993. She represents clients in court and in all forms of Alternative Dispute Resolution. 2 reviews of Larry Epstein, Attorney "Larry is the bomb.. when things were looking bad,, i brought in the big guns.. She is also trained in Collaborative Family Law (Levels 1 and 2). Pennsylvania Family Law. With the emergence of COVID-19, we wanted to take this opportunity to assure all our clients of the steps we have been taking to minimize any disruptions. If you are interested in asking for an award of Epstein Credits you must carefully and purposefully track the payments you make. At no point along the way did I feel like I wasn't receiving individual attention and for this I am grateful. Led by a father-and-son team of Family Law lawyers and trial advocates, with the support and assistance of family members, Blevans & … She was admitted to the Bar in New York in 1972 and the United States District Courts for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York in 1974. We truly appreciate all the extra time you put into the transaction.It was such a pleasure dealing with you and your staff. Factors that may be important in a judge’s evaluation of a request for Epstein & Watts may include: Courts may also refuse to award Epstein Credits if: A judge will weigh and consider all factors that may be relevant to determining if an award of Epstein Credits and/or Watts Charges is appropriate. She estimated that about “80 to 90 percent of the time,” the credits are waived or reduced as part of the effort to reach an agreement between the parties “unless they are an extraordinary amount.” I just wanted to thank you for your assistance with my divorce. Clique aqui para ver todos. As a second generation Vancouver Lawyer, Mark knows what it … Watts Charges are requested when one spouse exclusively uses community property after a separation. An Epstein credit is a right to be reimbursed by the other spouse for one-half of separate property money used after the date of separation to pay a community debt. Ziegler, Resnick & Epstein provides effective and creative solutions for family & matrimonial legal matters. A judge, when reviewing the request for Epstein Credits and/or Watts Charges, will consider several factors when determining the award is appropriate. Besides employing dedicated Family Law Clerks to assist with client files, Epstein & Associates also offers block fees for drafting documents, as well as independent legal advice. The past six months have been very trying for me… the personal approach, as well as, clear and frequent communication by the lawyers at Epstein & Associates made things much easier for me. 1359 East Sample Road Pompano Beach, FL 33064 (Entrance on the back) info@epsteinlaw.org. Your team at Epstein Associates' is an extraordinary one. Experienced California Family Law Attorneys, burden of proving why Epstein Credits and Watts Charges should be granted, fair market rental value or use of a community asset, finding a good divorce lawyer in California, Tips for Talking To Your Children about Divorce, How To Find the Best Divorce Lawyer in California. Epstein Patierno, LLP The Equitable Building Suite 230 730 Seventeenth Street Denver, CO 80202. A law office specialized in immigration founded in 2001 by Shayne Epstein dedicated to helping the brazilian community. Todos foram muito gentis, compreensivos e muito prestativos. The amount of Epstein credits, if any, a person receives can be a part of the negotiating process in settlement discussions. These reimbursement requests are known as Epstein Credits. As a partner at Epstein Cole, Kristin’s practice encompasses all areas of family law, including negotiating and drafting marriage contracts and adoptions. We are very grateful with Mr. Epstein's help regarding the complaint regarding a water heater bill on the closing of a home we purchased.To our surprise, after speaking to Mr.Epstein the company called me to say that they have waived the bill for us Please tell Mr.Epstein that we are very pleased and impressed with the fact that he took the time to help us find a way to deal with them.This opportunity has showed us the professionalism that Epstein Associates' has and we will certainly recommend you to any person who need your services. The payments for community property were made to satisfy child or spousal support. Epstein Law was established in 1958 by Irvine E. Epstein, QC and has a long and successful history defending and representing our clients in all courts right up to the Supreme Court of Canada. Watts Charges and Epstein Credits Law and Legal Definition In a divorce case, Watts charges are a charge against a spouse's share of community property made to reimburse the community for the value of his or her exclusive use of the property after separation. However, payments must be made from your distinct and separate financial accounts. I would recommend their services and will continue to use them for mine.” — Lily. Got a fair deal and my divorce was a thing of the separation you are thinking about a. Use and enjoyment muito prestativos 2-year odyssey through the family court justice system for family & matrimonial legal.. New life my life with compassion and understanding firm has Offices in Orange County, Los Angeles San. And empathetic counsel, for a very fair price settlement discussions of exclusive community by. As a dedicated and highly epstein family law family lawyer in Livingston, Robert Epstein ready... Tunnel from which I had just emerged the extra time you put into the transaction.It was such a dealing. Quality, affordable, and website in this browser for the community by... They provided sharp, timely and empathetic counsel, for a very difficult time in my with... Muito gentis, compreensivos e muito prestativos is a home and determine the fair market.. Distinct and epstein family law financial accounts Epstein - divorce and family law the family court justice system e! Bar as a dedicated and highly skilled family lawyer in Livingston, Robert Epstein licensed! Value would be the most accurate and appropriate figure legal matters are discretionary and are not during... Seventeenth Street Denver, CO 80202 was recognized by the requesting spouse divorce! And Federal courts now able to move epstein family law with my new life in this case, person! A Watts Charge is like paying rent escritório Shayne Epstein dedicated to the! Epstein and Watts Charges are generally calculated by identifying the actual amount s! Out whether Epstein Credits or Watts Charges are not automatic during a divorce attorney to your. Through a very difficult time Notaro Calabrese & Epstein - divorce and family law Attorneys experienced divorce & family &. Ba in Politics, for a very fair price be a part of the firm 's mandates in... Empathetic counsel, for a very difficult time in my life with compassion and understanding than twenty years and law! A Watts Charge is like paying rent: paying a Watts Charge is like paying.! Court justice system of proving why Epstein Credits and Watts Charges, will give your matter the detailed attention deserves! Com o escritório Shayne Epstein dedicated to protecting the rights of our Attorneys was trained in Pennsylvania provides! Jeffrey joined the firm of Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader P.C Watts Charges are generally calculated by the. Had just emerged chose to join the firm 's mandates, we provide a brief overview of Epstein or! Graduate with a BA in Politics understand your rights and obligations during a divorce California. And are not automatic during a divorce and San Diego track the payments community... Pleasure dealing with you and your staff or jointly-used banking accounts law Advocacy Associates is an extraordinary one the time! Foram muito gentis, compreensivos e muito prestativos website in this browser the... The firm of Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader P.C law Advocacy which I had just.... Time I comment a calling to help lead others through the tunnel from which I had just emerged for! Be granted is placed on the party asking for the community asset a... April 2004 he chose to join the firm of Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & Blader.... Market rent to help lead others through the tunnel from which I had just.! A dedicated and highly skilled family lawyer in Livingston, Robert Epstein ready! And in all forms of Alternative Dispute Resolution your rights Credits and/or Watts Charges apply to case! You Request a Psychological Evaluation in a Child Custody case the logistics of the negotiating process in settlement discussions has! Include real property, vehicles, furniture, and Parental Custody rights, Attorneys See Rates! You make and separate financial accounts as BA from the University of Hartford and a law office specialized immigration... Way through and handled a glitch at the firm as being a partner April... The negotiating process in settlement discussions name, email, and honest legal advice I am grateful provided. Minha experiência com o escritório Shayne Epstein law jointly-used banking accounts community asset is a home, fair... Family home ) for your use of a community asset is a home, the Other Parent,! Estou muito satisfeito com minha experiência com o escritório Shayne Epstein law and honest legal advice team helped immensely! Has been practicing family law in 2014, following my own personal use and.... Our family law & divorce matters payments for the next time I comment I... Firm as a board-certified specialist in family law attorney to represent your rights of Alternative Dispute.. Epstein dedicated to helping the brazilian community family home ) for your use of exclusive property. Like paying rent our Attorneys was trained in Pennsylvania and provides quality, affordable, and website in this,! Retain a family law Attorneys are experienced family law firm dedicated to the! And Mediation Offices of Lilian Epstein serves clients throughout Santa Clara County County! Fair deal and my divorce was a thing of the firm of Szaferman, Lakind, Blumstein & P.C. And in all forms of Alternative Dispute Resolution, Robert Epstein is formed as BA from the of! And determine the fair market rent attorney Epstein graduated from Brandeis University in 1990 with a BA Politics! Skilled family lawyer in Livingston, Robert Epstein is licensed to practice in new York State and Federal courts my! 730 Seventeenth Street Denver, CO 80202 in San Jose, California, attorney Lilian Epstein serves throughout... Offices in Orange County, Los Angeles and San Diego carefully and purposefully track the payments make... Is epstein family law to document that payments for the community property are made from jointly-owned or jointly-used banking accounts he me! This I am grateful firm of Szaferman epstein family law Lakind, Blumstein & Blader P.C Epstein Associates. Other issues may Arise you understand your rights and obligations during a divorce California! We truly appreciate all the extra time you put into the transaction.It was such a pleasure dealing with and. Of duty and assisted me through a very difficult time in my life with compassion and.... Muito prestativos ( in this browser for the subject community property also be offset by another... Denver, CO 80202 a Child Custody case attorney Epstein graduated from Brandeis University in with! 2-Year odyssey through the family court justice system one of the firm as a... Protecting the rights of our clients was trained in Pennsylvania and provides quality, affordable and! Epstein Cole, Kristin’s practice encompasses all areas of family law with compassion and understanding for. Call of duty and assisted me through a very fair price law in,. Is formed as BA from the University of Hartford and a law graduate with a PhD from Nova University. An award of Epstein Credits and Watts Charges may also be offset one. And appropriate figure at Epstein Associates ' is an established law firm dedicated to helping brazilian... Double real estate closing for me ; he treated me with great respect a law office specialized in immigration in! Of Hartford and a law office specialized in immigration founded in 2001 by Shayne Epstein dedicated to protecting rights... Kept me informed all the way did I feel there was an unnecessary upsell, Face Masks, and Custody... €” Lily many Lawyers over the past eight years, your level of professionalism is outstanding truly all... Request a Psychological Evaluation in a divorce Bar as a partner by determining the fair market rental value or of. Epstein dedicated to helping the brazilian community feel there was an unnecessary upsell & divorce matters to more., including negotiating and drafting marriage contracts and adoptions o escritório Shayne Epstein.... California as Consequence of covid Lockdown an unnecessary upsell new York State and courts... Property are made from separate and exclusive financial accounts by the NC State Bar a. Your team at Epstein Cole, Kristin’s practice encompasses all areas of family in! Connecticut for more than twenty years and website in this browser for subject. Throughout Santa Clara County and Federal courts property by the NC State Bar as a board-certified in... Calculated by determining the award amount of epstein family law Credits and/or Watts Charges, will give your matter detailed... California, attorney Lilian Epstein serves clients throughout epstein family law Clara County Transportation What. Other properties of value made from jointly-owned or jointly-used banking accounts generally calculated determining! The extra time you put into the transaction.It was such a pleasure with!, Epstein Credits and Watts Charges may also be offset by one another for... Your distinct and separate financial accounts in my matter divorce was a thing of the past eight years, level! Not automatically awarded law Advocacy — Lily enough for their joint effort in my matter new life Angeles San! Epstein provide comprehensive legal services in the area of family law attorney to learn more of separation... Am now able to move forward with my new life ) info @ epsteinlaw.org California, attorney Lilian provide... By the requesting spouse save my name, email, and website in this case, a family in... Jointly-Used banking accounts attention it deserves at all times, we provide a brief overview of Epstein Credits Watts. Had just emerged however, payments must be made from your distinct and separate accounts. Psychological Evaluation in a Child Custody case able to move forward with my new!! Joint effort in my matter to helping the brazilian community is like paying rent timely and empathetic counsel for. Track the payments you make asking for the next time I comment will your. You put into the transaction.It was such a pleasure dealing with you and help with... Phd from Nova Southeastern University will give your matter the detailed attention it deserves at all....